Best Pizza in Newtown Square

Q: Where are you located?

We are located in Newtown Square, PA at 3525 West Chester Pike

Real Pizza. Made by Family. Loved by Neighbors.

Grandma-Style Squares and Bar Pies

The 18-inch grandma square is golden and crispy-edged. The 16-inch bar pie is thin, crispy, and charred to perfection. Pick your style — or get both.

See the Menu

The Rosemary Potato Pie

People drive from South Philly for this one. Sliced potatoes, rosemary, and melted cheese on our grandma-style crust — simple ingredients, serious result.

Sauce On Top, AlwaysMozzarella Goes Down FirstSquare. Round. Always Fresh.Worth the Drive from the CityCHEESESTEAKS YOU WONT FORGETSauce On Top, AlwaysMozzarella Goes Down FirstSquare. Round. Always Fresh.Worth the Drive from the CityCHEESESTEAKS YOU WONT FORGETSauce On Top, AlwaysMozzarella Goes Down FirstSquare. Round. Always Fresh.Worth the Drive from the CityCHEESESTEAKS YOU WONT FORGETSauce On Top, AlwaysMozzarella Goes Down FirstSquare. Round. Always Fresh.Worth the Drive from the CityCHEESESTEAKS YOU WONT FORGETSauce On Top, AlwaysMozzarella Goes Down FirstSquare. Round. Always Fresh.Worth the Drive from the CityCHEESESTEAKS YOU WONT FORGETSauce On Top, AlwaysMozzarella Goes Down FirstSquare. Round. Always Fresh.Worth the Drive from the CityCHEESESTEAKS YOU WONT FORGETSauce On Top, AlwaysMozzarella Goes Down FirstSquare. Round. Always Fresh.Worth the Drive from the CityCHEESESTEAKS YOU WONT FORGETSauce On Top, AlwaysMozzarella Goes Down FirstSquare. Round. Always Fresh.Worth the Drive from the CityCHEESESTEAKS YOU WONT FORGET

Fresh Out of the Oven

Grandmother's Recipe, Neighborhood's Pizza

Malatesta's was built on one rule: mozzarella down first, sauce on top. That recipe hasn't changed — and neither has the commitment behind it.

What our guests are saying

Drove all the way from South Philly to try the white rosemary potato pizza at Malatesta’s and it was definitely DELISH. The flavor combination was incredible — perfectly balanced, fresh, and something you just don’t find everywhere. Truly one of those specialty pies that stands out. The quality of the pizza, the crust, and the attention to detail were all top notch. You can tell they take real pride in what they serve. This is one of those places worth traveling for. Next trip I’m coming back

Victor Baldi

My family and I REALLY enjoyed this pizza! (One pie was plenty for 3 people.) We ordered the Pepperoni Pie and it was delicious! The sauce was slightly sweet, and the crust was perfectly cooked. The cheese combination was spot on too! Definitely recommend if you’re looking for a good pizza in the NS area! We will definitely be ordering from here again soon!

Hallee Kondrich

Very good experience last night with Malatesta’s. I ordered 24 hours in advance using online ordering. The pizzas were delivered on time and warm and driver was friendly. A text message helped me track so I was worry free. The pizzas were delicious too!

Tara Zlotkin

Featured

View menu

Welcome to Malatesta Pizza and Cheesesteaks

Newtown Square's go-to for pizza and cheesesteaks! 🍕🥩 We're a family-owned spot rooted in Italian tradition, serving up classic and specialty pies, hearty cheesesteaks, and quick meals for the whole crew. Fresh prep, clean kitchen, fast service. Order takeout or delivery today!

Order Online